Non-parametric adjustment for covariates when estimating a treatment effect
نویسندگان
چکیده
We consider a non-parametric model for estimating the effect of a binary treatment on an outcome variable while adjusting for an observed covariate. A naive procedure consists in performing two separate non-parametric regression of the response on the covariate: one with the treated individuals and the other with the untreated. The treatment effect is then obtained by taking the difference between the two fitted regression functions. This paper proposes a backfitting algorithm which uses all the data for the two above-mentioned nonparametric regression. We give theoretical results showing that the resulting estimator of the treatment effect can have lower finite sample variance. This improvement may be achieved at the cost of a larger bias. However, in a simulation study we observe that mean squared error is lowest for the proposed backfitting estimator. When more than one covariate is observed our backfitting estimator can still be applied by using the propensity score (probability of being treated for a given setup of the covariates). We illustrate the use of the backfitting estimator in a several covariate situation with data on a training program for individuals having faced social and economic problems.
منابع مشابه
Ratio of Mediator Probability Weighting for Estimating Natural Direct and Indirect Effects
Decomposing a total causal effect into natural direct and indirect effects is central to revealing causal mechanisms. Conventional methods achieve the decomposition by specifying an outcome model as a linear function of the treatment, the mediator, and the observed covariates under identification assumptions including the assumption of no interaction between treatment and mediator. Recent stati...
متن کاملA Statistics Colloquium
The problem of estimating average treatment effect is of fundamental importance when evaluating the effectiveness of medical treatments or social intervention policies. Most of the existing methods for estimating average treatment effect rely on some parametric assumptions onthe propensity score model or outcome regression model one way or the other. In reality, both models are prone to misspec...
متن کاملIncorporating covariates into multipoint association mapping in the case-parent design.
BACKGROUND/AIMS To improve the efficiency of disease locus localization in association mapping using case-parent designs and to assess or account for the main covariate effects and gene-covariate interaction effects, while localizing the disease locus. METHODS The present study extends a multipoint fine-mapping approach to incorporate covariates into the association mapping of case-parent des...
متن کاملBias Correction in Non-Differentiable Estimating Equations for Optimal Dynamic Regimes
A dynamic regime is a function that takes treatment and covariate history and baseline covariates as inputs and returns a decision to be made. Robins (2004) proposed g-estimation using structural nested mean models for making inference about the optimal regime in a multi-interval trial. The method provides clear advantages over traditional parametric approaches. Robins’ g-estimation method alwa...
متن کاملRegression and Weighting Methods for Causal Inference Using Instrumental Variables
Recent researches in econometrics and statistics have gained considerable insights into the use of instrumental variables (IVs) for causal inference. A basic idea is that IVs serve as an experimental handle, the turning of which may change each individual’s treatment status and, through and only through this effect, also change observed outcome. The average difference in observed outcome relati...
متن کامل